
Big ideas, new frameworks and some all-too-familiar challenges. After a day representing Rooster Punk at B2B Marketing’s ABM Conference, I’m left wondering whether we’ve made things more complicated than they need to be.
At B2B Marketing’s ABM Conference last week, Maria Winn (B2B CMO) stood up and asked the question that I suspect has been nagging at many a marketer’s mind: at what point does one-to-many ABM just become good old fashioned demand generation?
And more to the point: how do you articulate the difference when the business starts asking where its marketing budget is going?
It’s a great question. And one that got me wondering whether ABM might be having a bit of an identity crisis.
For a discipline that’s been around for decades, ABM still seems to be surrounded by a certain mystique. It’s often presented as the most sophisticated, technical and finely orchestrated corner of B2B marketing. Something of a dark art, requiring specialist knowledge, complex frameworks and an impressive number of acronyms.
And to be fair, ABM is not easy. The challenges of sales and marketing alignment, data quality, personalisation and measurement are real, persistent and deeply entrenched.
But as I listened to some brilliant minds sharing their latest thinking on the discipline, I couldn’t help noticing a pattern.
For all the new models, methodologies and frameworks, the fundamentals of what makes ABM effective don’t seem to have changed all that much. And, perhaps more provocatively, they’re not so different from the fundamentals of good marketing which we all know and (try to) make real.
Marketers bloody love a framework. Give us a difficult problem and we’ll find a way to put it into a Venn diagram, preferably with a few extra dimensions for good measure.
And I think there’s something quite psychologically reassuring about that.
Taking something messy, unpredictable and difficult to control, and organising it into a neat model gives us a sense of order. The illusion of method to the madness. The comforting impression that if we just follow the right steps, we might be able to tame the beast.
But I wonder whether there’s something else going on, too.
Sometimes, making a problem look complicated can help justify why it’s so difficult to solve in the first place. If the diagram has enough moving parts, perhaps we feel a little better about the fact that we’re still struggling to make it work.
Of course, frameworks have their place. But there’s a difference between something being difficult to do and difficult to understand. And I wonder whether, in our efforts to make ABM more sophisticated, we’ve sometimes lost sight of that distinction.
Because when you strip away the terminology, so much of what makes ABM effective comes down to familiar principles: getting under the skin of your audience, saying the right things, showing up in the right places and measuring what matters.
Which brings me back to Maria’s question: if we’re targeting groups of accounts with tailored messages and content, where exactly does ABM end and demand generation begin?
There are legitimate distinctions, of course. But perhaps the boundaries aren’t quite as rigid as we sometimes make them out to be.
Dare I ask (at the risk of being blacklisted from polite B2B society forever)... whether most so-called ‘ABM’ campaigns were really just audience segmentation in a fancier outfit all along?
Another recurring theme at the conference was the changing B2B buying journey.
We heard that buying groups now involve an average of 14 stakeholders, that 61% of the buying journey happens before first seller contact, and that 68% of buyers begin with a preferred vendor already in mind.
All compelling evidence for the importance of ABM, you might argue.
But listening to these statistics, our CSO Tony made an interesting observation. If buyers are increasingly choosing from a day 1 shortlist of suppliers they already know, isn’t that also a pretty compelling argument for building a famous brand?
After all, you can have the most sophisticated account targeting and personalisation strategy in the world. But if nobody knows who you are, or has any reason to prefer you, you’re starting on the back foot.
Of course, ABM can play an important role in building that familiarity and preference. The point isn’t that brand and ABM are competing approaches. It’s that they work together.
And perhaps that’s another reason to be wary of treating ABM as an entirely separate discipline, rather than one part of a much bigger marketing picture.
The frameworks may have changed – but the fundamentals are pretty familiar.
Nick Mason, Founder and CEO of Turtl, made a related point in his keynote about what he called ‘the counting trap’: our tendency to confuse what’s measurable with what’s meaningful.
It’s an interesting parallel. Just as frameworks can give us the illusion of control, metrics can give us the illusion of progress.
And with AI making it easier than ever to produce more of just about everything, perhaps we need to spend less time demonstrating how much we’re doing and more time questioning whether it’s making a difference.
If there’s one area of marketing that feels particularly ripe for AI-enabled transformation, it’s ABM.
After all, so much of what makes ABM difficult is the sheer amount of labour involved. The research, account intelligence, personalisation and orchestration of multiple channels and touchpoints.
Be still my beating heart. Because this is where it gets properly useful.
Not because AI is going to reinvent the fundamental principles of ABM, but because it could make those principles considerably easier to put into practice.
HUT 3 made this point rather neatly in their session, arguing that many of ABM’s most persistent challenges are, at heart, capacity problems. Their AI workflows offered a compelling example of how technology can help close that gap, from account intelligence and messaging to personalisation and measurement.
And I appreciated the practical thinking from Funnel Fuel, who explored how to make omnichannel ABM work harder: developing creative with channels in mind, measuring genuine engagement rather than just clicks, and paying attention to negative signals as well as positive ones.
For me, it’s this focus on making the fundamentals easier to execute, rather than endlessly reinventing them, that feels like a more productive direction for the discipline.
Of course, there’s a caveat. Making it easier to produce personalised content doesn’t necessarily make that content more insightful, creative or compelling. And as Nick Mason reminded us, more activity doesn’t automatically mean more impact.
At Rooster Punk, we talk a lot about the importance of humanizing and systemizing marketing. Using technology and smarter processes to take the labour out of execution, while creating more space for the human understanding, creativity and relationships that make marketing effective.
And perhaps that’s a useful lens through which to think about ABM’s next chapter.
I left the conference with plenty of food for thought, and a renewed appreciation for just how difficult good ABM can be.
But also a nagging question: if the underlying challenges haven’t changed, and the fundamentals of effective marketing remain much the same, do we really need to keep reinventing the theory?
Or might the next big step forward for ABM be rather less glamorous: getting better at putting what we already know into practice?
Perhaps that’s not an identity crisis after all. Just a case of remembering who you are.